So is Elisha Cuthbert cheating on her NHL boyfriend with another NHL guy? The Sun UK reported:

The athletic pair couldn't keep their hands off each other as they splashed around in the warm waters of Hawaii.
An onlooker said: "It's not hard to see why Elisha is in big demand. She looked fabulous.
"Although she battled with her bikini top in the waves not wanting to give anything away."

But turns out, the dude isn't who they think it was. Ooohh...what a mystery...